We’re off…. I’ll be doing a play by play. I would love it if you would rank the performances for me!
AMERICAN IDOL 9′s first live show. SQUEEEEE. So excited!
First up is Paige Miles, who is a pre-school teacher. We get a recap of Paige’s Idol journey so far. Then she is singing “It’s All Right Now” by Free. I didn’t think it was that great but she does have a great voice. Cook was MUCH better with this song. His was memorable, I don’t think Paige’s will be. Simon: Asks how old she is and tells her that out of all the girls she has the best voice, but the song choice was wrong. Kara: She disagrees, says the song was brilliant, cause it is a rock song with soul. But she didn’t like the chorus. Randy: Doesn’t think the song was right but showed her powerful voice. Great Job Ellen: To come on first you gotta be nervous. You were so there, present, I looked the song. » Read more: Top 24 Girls Night Recap and Play by Play