Anything you want to discuss, complaing about, give kudos to on tonights show? Post your comments here.
I am a West Coaster, so I would LOVE to hear what you guys on the East and Central time zones have to say. 
Order of Performance:
Performance Order:
1. Jasmine Murray
2. Matt Giraud
3. Jeannie
4. Nick Mitchell
5. Allison
6. Chris
7. Megan
8. Matt R
9. Jessie
10. Kai Kalama
11. Mishavonna Henson
12. Adam Lambert
Jasmine: Love Song (Spoilers right)
Matt G.- Viva La Vida (Spoiler right)
No spoilers yet?
Just one comment: Where are the spoilers????? LOL…
No spoilers on the dress rehearsal? I haven’t seen anything anywhere.
Nothing. It is all too quiet darn it.
Order:
1. Jasmine Murray
2. Matt Giraud
3. Jeanine Vales
4. Nick Mitchell
5. Allison Irahetta
6. Kris Allen
7. Megan Corkrey
8. Matt Breitzke
9. Jesse Langseth
10. Kai Kalama
11. Mishavonna Henson
12. Adam Lambert
Jasmine is singing “Love Song” by Sara Bareilles.
Well, my man Adam gets the pimp spot – no shock there. Jasmine is surprisingly thin sounding here. I think part of the problem is the sound system is just HORRIBLE this year.
Gotta give that a big “meh” from Jasmine. Very pitchy. Simple songs like this really really expose a thin voice.
Jasmin… and there goes one of the favorites for the girls…
Wow, Matt Giraud is going second? Ouch, that’s a tough spot to be. Didn’t Ricky go second last week?
Geesh Matt Giraud sounds AWFUL! OMG, it’s a pitchfest. Whew, two early strong contenders are blowin it hard core. I don’t recall his voice sounding this bad. Also, another terrible song choice.
I think he’s trying really, really hard to sound like Coldplay… Which isn’t going to bode well…
Too many people LOVE that song… And I don’t think it did it justice AT ALL. 0/2
Normund Gentle. Have my babies
Wow… That was pretty much horrendous also… WOW… 0/3
This is ouch!
A rough start again this week! Nerves and bad song choices! Go Norman!
Well, you can always count on Normund to be entertaining! lol… Sadly, he’s by far the best so far lol
What they just did to Jeanine was disgusting. To talk about someone’s legs and lips like that is unbelieveable. Now that stupid a**hole is on the stage acting like a fool and I hope he wins the entire show and this show comes to a sick end.
Holy Moly! Norman’s got big guts to do a performance like that and you’re so right Idol Battles, he is the best so far. Who knows with how the night has gone he may end up being the best!
oww…what did normund sing??
Normund “And I am telling you”
again? oh well.
Well, FINALLY! Allison rocked the house… and on a song I was very, very afraid of… I think she’s going to sail through
Well I couldn’t remember Allison before but that was INCREDIBLE!!! 0/3 before that. Though Norman was funny. Love Man in the Mirror, let’s see what he does!
Um, is it just me or are the background singers TOTALLY off-key tonight.
Wow Kris! Please don’t say he was boring, judges! He was great! Tonight is turning out to be WAY different than I thought! Good luck Jasmine, but I think you’re done after these two and Adam coming up…
You know, it HAS got to eb the sound system that is making these singers voices sound so thin tonight. No one’s voice has any timbre or resonance to it.
Terrible sound system – terrible backup singers.
Kris can for sure sing… But with the song… and the performance, he kinda reminds me of a N’Sync type artist… I think he had a great chance, and I agree with Kara and this was the way wrong song.
I thought tonight was gonna be amazing but so far it had completely sucked IMHO. I guess we are seeing what happens when you let 36 people perform instead of 24. You get a lot of suck.
So far the only one I have loved is Nick. I was dying. so funny
So far, seriously i have heard better music on karaoke night.
OMG MEGAN! AMAZING! Jeez! What is this? This was supposed to be the sucky night@
Megan’s voice is interesting, but very thin. I can see getting very tired of it.
Okay, I’m in LOVE… That’s the best of the night BY FAR… Megan Corkrey FTW!
Will you marry me?
Megan’s problem is that she is VERY shouty on the big notes. Very flat too. Loved the first part of the song, hated the second part. She could sound very good and interesting mixed in the studio.
HATIN the full arm tatoo on her. Why the heck would such a cute girl get that monstrosity on her arm? It makes no sense.
Agreed about the tattoo!
Man, all of these singers voices are just so thin. Right about now I am missing me some David Cook. Matt had some good momenst there, but when he had a chance to blow us away he just didn’t.
The problem is that these songs they are chosing don’t BUILD to anyything. The song has no MOMENT. Ugh, terrible night.
I love that song that Matt sang… But I don’t know if it’s the best song to sing on American Idol… Unless you’re completely amazing, and he wasn’t… good, not amazing…
I am thinking we might get two women and a man tonight. I am expecting Jesse to nail it – she is a pro.
I have always hated this song but she is singin it well. Excellent pitch. She is in Top 12 based on this.
I REALLY want to like her. She’s not as good as Allison and Megan though… Maybe a wildcard?
Jesse has pretty eyes… She’s not bad… Not great… Take about everything I said about Matt and it applies… Good, not great…
See and I feel like even if she goes through, she wont last long… Again, I really WANT to like her…
So far, I give tonight a 4 out of 10. This season so far has been a complete disappointment to me. Please Adam, save us from mediocrity.
Does Kai have the ability to sing more than one note? Listen to him. Every single not was exactly the same.
So, I am digging the song choice for Kai… The best guy thus far.. Although, that’s not incredibly difficult… And my parents, who are watching, loved it also…
I’m pretty sure he looks and sounds like an axe murderer. I am a little bit scared of him; I’m not gonna lie…
From what I’ve seen of the men tonight, Adam doesn’t even need to sing, he can just stand up there and take a bow and make the final 12.
FINALLY, a performance worthy of Idol from Mish. She is through.
Totally right about Adam. But seriously what is going with the girls?! Mishavonna! AMAZING!
<3… I’m so glad they saved the best for last… Mishavonna… HOT! Lovin’ it. Took a good song, made it her own without ruining it…
PS… they backup band should be fired, shot, and never allowed on TV, ever.. ever… ever… My god, they are terrible…
C’mon Adam, save us dude. You have it in you, I hope like heck you chose a good song.