A poster at EW gave a few clues as to what four contestants are singing this week.

Here’s what was posted:

This doesn’t have much to do with last week’s results, but I wanted to share some info on this week’s 12. I have ties to one of them (can’t say which one), and I have found out some of the possible song choices for this week. Sadly, not all. But I do know what at least 4 of them have been practicing (its only Mon, so they could change their minds. I know at least one has two possible songs they’ve been working on). I’m afraid to put the actual song names out there, but I do have some hints.  Rachel Mon 02/23/09 5:12 PM

Nick - This “salty” standard has been featured in film and covered numerous times, most notably in the 80s.

Adam – One singer of each gender has had a version of this wistful ballad reach the Billboard top 10.

Matt G – He takes a turn at a contemporary hit. Hopefully, Matt will live to sing another day.

Jasmine - Madonna had a hit with a different song with the same title as the recent hit that Jasmine is singing.

Let the guessing begin….

Normally, I try not to post stuff from peole I don’t know but since I’ve already spoiled what Matt Giraud will be singing this week, his makes sense.

UPDATE: One of our posters, BLUEWARE, posted this in comments and I thought I would bring it to the forefront so we could discuss it.  PLEASE PLEASE TAKE THIS LIST FOR WHAT IT IS – A RUMOR. I HAVE NO WAY TO VERIFY ANY OF THIS It looks like the clues match these songs, right? Perhaps they are accurate of perhaps someone saw the clues posted and made songs to fit the clues

Bluewave

Hey, JP, I found a list that was supposedly on Facebook but was quickly deleted, could you find out if these are accurate?

Adam Lambert- “All By Myself” Eric Carmen
Nick Mitchell – “Crying” Roy Orbison
Matt Breitzke-”How Am I Supposed to Live Without You” Michael Bolton
Kai Kalama-”Lean on Me” Club Nouveau
Kris Allen- “How You Remind Me” Nickelback
Matt Giraud – “Viva La Vida” Coldplay

Jeanine Vailes -”Love Will Lead You Back” Taylor Dayne
Allison Iraheta”Total Eclipse of the Heart” Bonnie Tyler
Meghan Cockrey- “Nothing Compares 2 U” Sinéad O’Connor
Jesse Langseth- “You Needed Me” Anne Murray
Mishavonna Henson-”With or Without You” U2
Jasmine Murray- “Love song” Sara Bareilles

Commentary

  1. Joes Place wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Here’s every song done by Madonna. Any song jup out as a recent hit Jasmine could be singing?
    A New Argentina
    Act Of Contrition
    Ain’t No Big Deal (’97 edit)
    Ain’t No Big Deal (’81 and ‘97 extended)
    Amazing
    American Life
    American Pie
    And The Money Kept Rolling In (And Out)
    Angel
    Another Suitcase In Another Hall
    Back In Business
    Bad Girl
    Be Careful With My Heart
    Beautiful Stranger
    Bedtime Story
    Bittersweet
    Borderline
    Buenos Aires
    Burning Up
    Burning Up (’81)
    Bye Bye Baby
    Can’t Stop
    Candy Perfume Girl
    Causing A Commotion
    Charity Concert/The Art Of The Possible
    Cherish
    A Cinema In Buenos Aires, 26 July 1952
    Crazy For You
    Crimes Of Passion
    Cry Baby
    Cyberraga
    Dear Jessie
    Deeper And Deeper
    Did You Do it?
    Die Another Day
    Don’t Cry For Me Argentina
    Don’t Cry For Me Argentina (Miami Spanglish Mix)
    Don’t Stop
    Don’t Tell Me
    Don’t You Know?
    Dress You Up
    Drowned World/Substitute For Love
    Each Time You Break My Heart
    Easy Ride
    Erotica
    Erotic (Sex Mix)
    Eva And Magaldi/Eva Beware Of The City
    Eva’s Final Broadcast
    Everybody
    Everybody (’97 and ‘81)
    Express Yourself
    Fever
    Forbidden Love
    Freedom
    Frozen
    Gambler
    Get Over
    Gone
    Gone, Gone, Gone
    Goodbye To Innocence
    Goodnight And Thank You
    Guilty By Association
    Hanky Panky
    Has To Be
    He’s A Man
    Hello And Goodbye
    High Flying, Adored
    Holiday
    Hollywood
    Hoy Que No Estas (Now That You’re Not Here)
    Human Nature
    I Deserve It
    I Know It
    I Surrender, Dear
    I Want You
    I’d Be Surprisingly Good For You
    I’d Rather Be Your Lover
    I’ll Remember
    I’m Going Bananas
    I’m So Stupid
    If You Forget Me
    Impressive Instant
    In This Life
    Inside Of Me
    Intervention
    Into The Groove
    Jimmy Jimmy
    Just A Dream
    Justify My Love
    Justify My Love (Beast Within)
    Keep It Together
    La Isla Bonita
    Lament
    Latin Chant
    Laugh To Keep From Crying
    Let Down Your Guard
    Like A Flower
    Like A Prayer
    Like A Virgin
    Little Star
    Live To Tell
    Lo Que Siente La Mujer (What The Woman Feels)
    Look Of Love, The
    Love Don’t Live Here Anymore
    Love Makes The World Go Round
    Love Profusion
    Love Song
    Love Tried To Welcome Me
    Love Won’t Wait
    Lucky Star
    Material Girl
    Mer Girl
    More
    Mother And Father
    Music
    Nobody’s Perfect
    Nobody Knows Me
    Nothing Fails
    Nothing Really Matters
    Now I’m Following You (p. I)
    Now I’m Following You (p. II)
    Oh Father
    Oh What A Circus
    On The Balcony Of The Casa Rosada 1
    On The Balcony Of The Casa Rosada 2
    On This Night Of A Thousand Stars
    One More Chance
    Open Your Heart
    Over And Over
    Papa Don’t Preach
    Paradise (Not For Me)
    Partido Feminista
    Peron’s Latest Flame
    Physical Attraction
    Power Of Good-Bye, The
    Pretender
    Promise To Try
    Queen’s English
    Rain
    Rainbow High
    Rainbow Tour
    Ray Of Light
    Requiem For Evita
    Rescue Me
    Revenge
    Runaway Lover
    Sanctuary
    Santa Baby
    Santa Evita
    Secret
    Secret Garden
    Shanti/Ashtangi
    She Is A Diamond
    Shoo-Bee-Doo
    Sidewalk Talk
    Skin
    Sky Fits Heaven
    Something To Remember
    Sooner Or Later
    Spanish Eyes
    Spotlight
    Stay
    Stay (’81)
    Supernatural
    Survival
    Swim
    Take A Bow
    The Actress Hasn’t Learned The Lines (You’d Like To Hear)
    The Funny Song
    The Lady’s Got Potential
    Thief Of Hearts
    Think Of Me
    This Used To Be My Playground
    Till Death Do Us Part
    Time Stood Still
    To Have And Not To Hold
    True Blue
    Up Down Suite
    Verás (You’ll See)
    Vogue
    Waiting
    Waltz For Eva And Che
    What Can You Lose
    What It Feels Like For A Girl
    Where Life Begins
    Where’s The Party
    White Heat
    Who’s That Girl
    Why’s It So Hard
    Words
    X-Static Process
    You Must Love Me
    You’ll See
    Your Honesty
    Your Little Body’s Slowly Breaking Down

  2. Ashley wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    here are the choices that jasmine could be singing:

    angel by natasha bedingfield
    love song by sara bareilles
    take a bow by rihanna
    burning up by the jonas brothers :P

    lol hmm im thinking its either gonna be love song by sara bareilles or take a bow by rihanna

  3. Joes Place wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Very Good, Ashley!!!

  4. Jordan wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Jasmine Murray is singing “Take A Bow” by Rihanna.

  5. Jordan Pack wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    The other ones are pretty hard to guess besides Jasmine.

    I’m guessing Nick/Normund will do something diva ish like “And I’m Telling You,” but idk.

    I thought maybe Adam was doing “I’ll Be There,” even though that’s so boring lol..but the Jackson 5 and Mariah Carey both took that song to #1.

    Matt Giraud is “Viva la Vida” which will be very interesting.

  6. x wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    How recent is recent?

    I came up with a few other ones for Jasmine:

    Amazing by Josh Kelley
    Bad Girl by Rhianna
    Gone by NSYNC
    I Want You by Savage Garden
    Over and Over by Tim McGraw and Nelly
    Stay (I Missed You) by Lisa Loeb (not a perfect match but a lot of people just call it Stay)

  7. Joes Place wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Choices for Adam:
    “I’ll Be There” — The Jackson 5 (1970) and Mariah Carey (1992)
    “Lady Marmalade” — Labelle (1975) and Christina Aguilera / Lil Kim / Mya / Pink (2001)

    Let me see if there’s more…

  8. Ramiele Jasmine Camile wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    She should sing alone, one last cry or you don’t have to say you love me.

  9. Joes Place wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Jordan: Are you sure thats it?

  10. Cassidy wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    So, it IS confirmed then? Matt Giraud is doing “Viva La Vida?”

  11. Jordan Pack wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    It can’t be “Lady Marmalade” because both artists are female.

  12. Jordan Pack wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Actually Matt Giraud could be doing “Fall For You” by Secondhand Serenade because the lyrics from the song go:

    “Don’t make me change my mind

    Or I won’t live to see another day”

  13. Joes Place wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    lol…Duh. Gosh, I don’t want him to sing the Jacksons. It’s hard to find top 10 songs. #1 songs were easy

  14. Joes Place wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    It’s Confirmed as of when I found out last week. I hate to put stuff out there to far in advance because there IS A CHANCE that contestants change songs at the last inute.

  15. Joes Place wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    It’s Confirmed as of when I found out last week. I hate to put stuff out there to far in advance because there IS A CHANCE that contestants change songs at the last inute.

  16. Joes Place wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Respect – Aretha Franklin (Otis Redding)
    No, thats not it. It states it is a “wistful ballad”

  17. Cassidy wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    From what I know of Matt and his musical style/taste…I think he would definitely be doing Coldplay over Secondhand Serenade! ;)

    Should be interesting to see! He’s pretty much the only one I care about in this group…

  18. Jordan Pack wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Jasmine could also be doing “Spotlight” by Jennifer Hudson, but I really think she’ll take the “Take A Bow” route.

  19. Lux wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    I think Adam´s song could be “All by myself”.

  20. Erika wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Okay so everyone over at the IDF Adam forum are thinking its “Without You” by Henry Nilsson/Mariah Carey…

  21. Ashley wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    ooh! yay thanks!

    so im liking jasmines possible song choice :)

  22. Joes Place wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    OOOO…i AM LOVING THIS CHOICE!

  23. Jordan Pack wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    It will be really interesting if Adam takes on huge songs like “Without You” and “All By Myself.”

    But it clearly won’t even matter if it’s mediocre because Danny was sooo mediocre with a Mariah Carey song and the judges were jumping up and down over it (except for Simon of course).

  24. Erika wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Joes Place… what song was that in reference too?

    And I think Adam could take on any of those songs much better than Danny did, honestly.

  25. dhealy2003 wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    I’m guessing Jasmine is doing “Spotlight.” Although “Take a Bow” is a good possibility.

    My initial guess for Adam is “All By Myself.” It was first a hit by Eric Carmen, then Celine Dion.

    Of course Matt’s doing “Viva La Vida.”

    Not sure about Nick. Could be “Time After Time.” That’s probably the most covered song ever. lol

  26. Joes Place wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Cassidy. He’s Doing Coldplay. He was my Hint last week.

  27. Joes Place wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Erika: Without you.

  28. Erika wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    yeah I think that would be a great choice for him. He could show off his low range in the verses and hit the high notes in the chorus… its such a tough song but I really think it will establish him as possibly one of the best vocalists this season…

  29. Erin wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Take a Bow sounds like a good song choice for Jasmine. I think she’ll do pretty well.

    I am confused about Matt’s clue for his song choice, but if he is singing the Coldplay song, I think he’ll be fine.

    “Without You” is a really hard song to sing so if this is definitely Adam’s song choice, it will be either a hit or miss. However, considering he is one of the best male singers this season, I think he could pull it off. He could even get the last spot in performance order if he does a great job.

  30. Peter wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Did we ever figure out what Nick(Normond) was doing.

    We said Jasmine was doing Take A Bow right?

    What was Adam Doing?

    And Matt is doing Viva La Vida right?

  31. Laura wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    the ’salty’ one for Nick could be puttin on the ritz…though that’s pretty awful as songs go, for me anyway.

  32. Laura wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    That said though, I could see him doing it as Norman Gentle – ‘Puttin’ on the Ritz’ actually sounds very Norman, doesn’t it?

  33. Peter wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Normond’s song could be (I Can’t Get No) Satisfaction. It’s been used in a movie called Starman and has been covered almost 100 times. I could see him singing this. JoesPlace, is this the right song?????????

  34. Peter wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    As of right now I am guessing that Normond/Nick is singing (I can’t get no) Satisfaction, Jasmine is singing Take A Bow, Matt is singing Viva La Vida, and Adam is singing I’ll Be There. Is this right?

  35. linny wrote on 23. Feb 2009
  36. Erin wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    I honestly hope Adam doesn’t sing I’ll Be There. That song ha very little range. My guess is still Without You.

  37. megg wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Adam maybe singing “Against All Odds” ???

    Sung by both Mariah Carey and Phil Collins

  38. rhonda wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    What does I can’t get no satisfaction have to do with the “salty” clue? I think its more likely Puttin on the Ritz, and the salty of course is in reference to ritz crackers. There was a famous rendition of that song done in the 80s.

  39. josh wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    rumors are that kris allen is singing michael jackson’s “man in the mirror”. anybody else heard this?

  40. Jason wrote on 23. Feb 2009

    Jasmine could sing “Spotlight” by Jennifer Hudson? That was one of Madonna’s songs too.

  41. Vickers wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    I think Nick’s “salty” song is “(Sittin’ On) The Dock of the Bay”….it’s been a #1 on the Billboard 100, been featured on various soundtracks including Top Gun (1986), been covered a bazillion times most notably in 1988 by Michael Bolton. Does that cover everything?

  42. Chad wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    The ’salty’ term could have something to do with Normund Gentle’s intro video … right?

    I think Adam (based on what I heard him say on tv) wants to change up his songs like David Cook did, so I’m thinking he can pick any song and change it up differently.

    Question:
    Since nobody used instruments last week, does that mean instruments aren’t allowed this stage? I’d like to see Giraud back on the piano for Vida la Vida.

  43. yoshi wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    adam – possibly “endless love”???lionel riche and diana ross’s version made the top 10 and so did the luther vandross, mariah version

    it seems like jasmine will sing take a bow and matt will definitely sing viva la vida

    not sure about nick – maybe “dont you forget about me”??

  44. Bill Mitchell wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Why not “Dust in the Wind” for Adam?

  45. Beth wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Just a Dream could also be done by Jasmine.

  46. John wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Just like last week, the contestants have to sing songs from the Billboard “Hot 100″ chart, from any year since the chart began.

  47. Bluewave wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Hey, JP, I found a list that was supposedly on Facebook but was quickly deleted, could you find out if these are accurate?

    Adam Lambert- “All By Myself” Eric Carmen
    Nick Mitchell – “Crying” Roy Orbison
    Matt Breitzke-”How Am I Supposed to Live Without You” Michael Bolton
    Kai Kalama-”Lean on Me” Club Nouveau
    Kris Allen- “How You Remind Me” Nickelback
    Matt Giraud – “Viva La Vida” Coldplay

    Jeanine Vailes -”Love Will Lead You Back” Taylor Dayne
    Allison Iraheta”Total Eclipse of the Heart” Bonnie Tyler
    Meghan Cockrey- “Nothing Compares 2 U” Sinéad O’Connor
    Jesse Langseth- “You Needed Me” Anne Murray
    Mishavonna Henson-”With or Without You” U2
    Jasmine Murray- “Love song” Sara Bareilles

  48. Missy wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    I heard Adam was doing ‘Cryin by Aerosmith. Faith Hill had a ‘Cryin hit, but they aren’t the same song. And I wouldn’t call Aerosmith ‘wistful’.

  49. Kath wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Oh Adam. Not a “wistful ballad” :-(

    If he sang Lady Marmalade, I’d vote until my fingers bled.

  50. Missy wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    I’d also kill to hear him sing Lady Marmalade. I’m very afraid of him starting with a ballad, after the Cher choice. He needed to bring some rock this week. There is always wild card if he picks a bad song. He can sing anything, I don’t understand picking a “wistful ballad.”

  51. Sara wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Does ANYONE actually know Adam and is monitoring these boards? Can someone get him a message that his fans do NOT want another pop ballad right now? I am such a huge fan and I want him to advance, but I am worried…. Someone please get him a message that if he wants to win, he needs to be this year’s rocker.

  52. Missy wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Although his version of ‘I Just Love You’ is beautiful, if he’s going to pick a ballad, that’s a version to pick. At least it’s contemporary.

  53. Brian wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    The first thing I thought of for Jasmine was “Take a Bow”. It was a huge hit for Madonna back in the early 90’s and Rihanna did a song last year with the same title.

  54. suebrody wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Yeah, Adam needs to go big. All by Myself is really boring. *yawn* I don’t think they get instruments, b/c they are using pre-recorded music (stupid). I would like Sitting By the Dock of the Bay, though, b/c you can really switch that one up, but I would still go bigger. Lady Marmalade would be amazing, if he nailed it, and it could easily send him into to the Top 12.

    I think it’s a little risky for Matt to do Coldplay, b/c Viva La Vida is still charting, and will be automatically compared to Coldplay.

    That said, I totally see Jasmine doing Rhianna. Angel by Natasha Bedingfield is also a good bet.

    And anyone who picks a Michael Jackson or Jackson Five song is REALLY looking for trouble, IMO, after last week’s disaster. Only David Cook gets to do it (after Billie Jean, how can you even try an MJ song?). If Kris picks MJ, he has officially shot himself in the foot.

    I’m a little surprised that this stuff is getting leaked out, but there are always spoilers, I guess. It all depends on how the singer does (or who is the favorite). I am still shaking my head over Michael Sarver. Blah song, blah performance. Anoop should have taken it over him, if the votes were really that close.

    And I hate to say it, but I only remember the guys and Jasmine and Meghan, for what it’s worth. The guys are TOTALLY gonna take it this year. Poor guys. Too much competition. I wish only guys could win for the next two weeks.

  55. hollygo72 wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    While I would LOVE for Meghan to sing “Nothing Compares 2 U”, I have a hard time believing that Prince would clear the rights for one of his songs on AI. He’s notorioiusly controlling over his music.

  56. Cassidy wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Suebrody – apparently, Matt does “Viva La Vida” as part of his set list back home and has his own “twist” on it. :) It’s a big hit where he plays, so I am confident that he will do well with it! No risk, no reward right?

    That rumored song list from Facebook, looks quite accurate. Hmm…I wonder? There are a lot of strange choices though. Some songs are contemporary hits while others are old school!

  57. Krisfan wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    I definitely do NOT see Kris singing Nickelback. His voice is not deep enough to really handle that song. I think he’s pick something more from the likes of Lifehouse or something in that area or a soul song. If he actually did choose Nickelback, he’s made a mistake.

  58. sara wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Another possible song for Adam has come to mind just now. Meatloaf and Celine Dion both sang It’s all coming back to me now” and I am sure both were top 10 hits…

  59. Missy wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Think there is any way Adam can rock up “All By Myself”, speed it up, mix it up? I’m very afraid if this is his choice. He can sing ANYTHING and this song is so boring and overdone.

  60. Missy wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    ooh, now that is a much better idea, Meatloaf!

  61. Sara wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Another reason the Meatloaf song comes to mind is that Meatloaf and Katherine McPhee performed it in the finale of her season, but I don’t think anyone else has ever sang it. I love that song. I hate All By Myself. I am really hoping that spoiler is wrong.

  62. Bryant wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    IMO the Meatloaf/Celine Dion song would definitely a more interesting pick than “All By Myself”, although I find both songs a little too schmaltzy (not in a good way), for lack of a better word. “Without You” (done the Nilsson/Mariah way, NOT with the soulless but vocally proficient Kelly Clarkson/Leona Lewis approach) has the potential to be a great performance in terms of technique AND the all-important emotional connection.

  63. Missy wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Another rumor is 4 non blondes, but who knows..

  64. angela wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    everyone needs to listen to kris allen doing over the rainbow on youtube – it is amazing – he is the best in season 8 but no one knows because of no screen time!

  65. Joes Place wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Yes, I posted it here a couple of weeks ago.

  66. Missy wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    I’d much prefer “Without You” to “All by Myself” not that I like either one really.

  67. Missy wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Kris has nothing on Adam. He’s the best singer AI has ever seen.

  68. Lera wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    I do not see Nick singing “Crying” that is just not for nick or normund. He will do a soulful type song, I liked Sitting on the dock of the bay suggestion, but “sea of love” was in a film, and sung by contestants in the past. And for Normunds routine I think “Margaritaville” would be in play.

    I have no idea but “Crying” just doesn’t fit.

  69. Katy wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    I think that the song list just took the clues from EW, guessed for themselves and then put some random ones in for other ones, but who knows. We all laughed at last weeks list before it was confirmed.

  70. suebrody wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    My thought: Do NOT pick a song that another singer did really well. Comparisons will abound. Be careful about songs that are out RIGHT NOW (Coldplay, Rhianna), b/c, again, comparisons will abound. Pick songs that are typical of your style, with maybe an interpretation but don’t go pick something totally unsuitable (e.g., Casey singing Every Little Thing (He) Does is Crazy–not a smart move). It’s tough to pick a song that will highlight everything you want, especially without a backing band OR an instrument, but it’s possible. As long as it showcases your style and your highlights, it should work out. I think it’s tricky to get too interpretive this soon (so you wonder about Matt doing Viva La Vida, more b/c it’s out now than b/c he can do cool things with it :) ).

    I would love to hear Meatloaf! But if I hear any Mariah or Whitney or Leona…ugh. What about Britney or Christina? (Just to change up things.) And if you choose Michael Bolton (Matt B.), you have already taken yourself out of the competition, IMO. *yawn* I really don’t think he will make it out of this round, the way Michael did last week. There are just too many other strong singers, and I think America will go, Oh, no, look what happened (no Anoop, no Ricky, no Ann Marie, etc.) and will pick up the phone.

  71. Peter wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Was the Puttin on the Ritz song ever in a movie and was it covered alot.

  72. Jason wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    I think Adam could be singing these songs:

    “Without You” _Mariah Carey, Harry Neilson
    “All By Myself”- Celine Dion, Eric Carmen (I think it will be this one)
    “Cryin’” -Patsy Cline, Roy Orbison

    Nelson will probably sing “Puttin’ on the Ritz” by Taco
    Jazmine is obviously doing “Take A Bow” by Rihanna

  73. Nick wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Nick is not singing “Ritz”…guaranteed.

  74. Nick wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    All signs point toward “Sea of Love”

  75. Joes Place wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    There’s no way it’s Sea of Love. It does not fit the clues

  76. Nick wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    What clues doesn’t it fit?

  77. Erika wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    “All Coming Back To Me” would be an interesting song choice for Adam. David Hernandez sang that last year and did a pretty good job. Not sure why people are so apprehensive about “All By Myself” though. Adam has incredible rang and this song is really challenging. I think he could establish himself as one of the best singers this season with that song.

  78. PETER wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    So Nick is singing Puttin on the Ritz.
    Jasmine is singing Take A Bow.
    Matt is singing Viva La Vida.
    But what is Adam Singing, Is it All By Myself or All By Myself? I still don’t understand the clue. JoesPlace can you give us another clue for Adam?PLEASE!!!!!!!!!

  79. ruanke wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    I have two favorite songs over the past 6 months. “Time of my Life” and “Viva la Vida”.

    Cook was my favorite last year.

    Giraud is my favorite this year. Therefore, “Viva la Vida” sounds okay with me. GO MATT!!

    You ARE the only one I care about this season

  80. erinnthered wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    JP, “Sea of Love” does fit the clues. It was the title of a big Al Pacino movie from the 80’s. Ellen Barkin and John Goodman co-star. One of my favorites, actually. Plus, it has been covered by everyone from Tom Waits (my fave) to IZ Kamakawiwo’ole. It was the first thing I thought of too, Lera.

  81. Lera wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    I love sea of love, listen to Robert Plants version. It’s absouletly a great song. I just hope Nick can sing it well. If he is indeed doing “Sea of Love” then Nick isn’t going to do it as Normund, he is going straight on this one.

  82. Lera wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    Here is a link to Robert Plant singing “Sea of Love”
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8EOkTmkuS3I

    I have this song by him on my PC and listen to it often.

  83. Anon wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    He’s should sing “Tears of a Clown” as Normund

  84. T wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    VFTW mentioned that one of Adam’s choices could be “True Colors” by Cyndi Lauper and then covered by Phil Collins. I listened to the song again and I forgot how beautiful it is and how much I loved it! OMG, if Adam did this song, I would die happy. Such a beautiful song with a beautiful meaning. Very fitting for him and subtle at the same time.

    I would take this song over the Celine or Mariah cover anyday. Please let it be “True Colors”!

  85. T wrote on 24. Feb 2009

    The song was a #1 Billboard Hit for Cyndi and I believe it was #2 for Phil Collins as well.

    Here is a link to “True Colors”

    Cyndi Lauper version: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gZFbyEKBYNY

    Phil Collins version: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rmfqLOLCNi8

  86. patrick wrote on 25. Feb 2009

    i love that song!!! (sea of love) AND… it kinda does fit the clues. it is a standard, and it has to do with salt: the sea is made of salt water. kinda works. lmao. and i could totally picture nick singing this.

  87. Missy wrote on 25. Feb 2009

    True Colors would be so much better than Mariah or Celine. At least Adam has us guessing!

  88. Lera wrote on 25. Feb 2009

    We will all find out later tonight! Unless Joe gets some fantastic spoilers early. I’ll be watching throughout the day. Thanks much, Joesplace.

    Lera

  89. Lera wrote on 25. Feb 2009

    Sea of Love

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_of_Love_(song)I just read that Robert Plant started the group the Honeydippers, they only recorded 2 songs as that group. They formed it because they wanted to play some heavy R&B music but it really didn’t take off. “Sea of Love” is a re-recording of an old song and as you can see by the link, it was covered a lot.

    Everything about this song fits the clues, and given the History of the song itself bodes well for Normund. He is that R&B guy!

    This is enough of that I promise. I just didn’t think Crying really fit Normund or Nick. IT just wasn’t him you know? *shrugs* I could be wrong.

  90. Cassidy wrote on 25. Feb 2009

    All of the rumored song choices for Adam just make me think…hmm…how would he ever be a mainstream artist? Just my opinion of course…

  91. Missy wrote on 25. Feb 2009

    I think he’s just trying to show his voice enough to get in the Top 12. After that we’ll get to see more personality, hopefully he’ll glam it up more. Just my opinion of course for me too.

  92. Heather wrote on 25. Feb 2009

    Yea, Adam. He’s gotta prove himself vocally now. Also don’t forget sometimes they can’t get like ANY damn song approved. I think Adam is totally marketable. But for now he’s gotta tone it down to get the middle America vote.

    I like Without You! Clay Aiken has sang the ish out of it.. I could see All My Myself too. I just think he’d pick something more.. rockish?

  93. Josh wrote on 25. Feb 2009

    That rumored list actually seems real. They all match the little riddles given earlier this week.

  94. DesaiLambert wrote on 25. Feb 2009

    Adam will do amazing with whatever song he picks but I’d love it if he did “Without You”. That song would suit his voice well. I think he’d nail it. “Against All Odds” would be another good choice for him. And I’m also SO excited for Nick! Haha – love him! Cannot wait! ;)

  95. g. ludwig wrote on 25. Feb 2009

    oh please be wrong about “All By Myself” for Adam; it’s just too sappy! He knows how important song choice is so I have to have faith that he’ll pick something just great; we’d love to hear him sing “What’s Up” by 4 Non Blondes – he nailed that on his videos. “Without You” is one of my all time favorites, the Nilson version – so touching & Adam could pull it off! :) should be a fun night!

  96. Sara wrote on 25. Feb 2009

    Adam was told over the weekend he could not perform the song of his choosing. As of Monday night he still did not have a song. This info is from a post by a fellow Wicked cast member. We don’t know yet what song he wanted to sing… Same old crap from AI….

  97. Joes Place wrote on 25. Feb 2009

    Hy, Sarah, where did you see the post from the Wicked Cast member? Can youplease post a link? TY :)

  98. 24 spoilers wrote on 02. Mar 2009

    Thanks dude, your post is very informative, nice post !!!

  1. American Idol Top 36 Round Deux (IFFY) SPOILERS « Top Idol on 24. Feb 2009